If you thought the Itemization threads on the EQ2 Forums have been harsh, they really took a turn for the worse after players took Silius‘ advice and checked out the changes on Test and Test Copy, only to find that several items had lost upwards of 75% of their MultiAttack, 4.0 weapons received additional boosts (leaving out 6.0 weapons), and most of the ‘boosts’ were upwards of 0.6% increases on just a handful of stats.
SmokeJumper came to Silius‘ defense:
Silius has made huge strides into setting things up so that the completely haphazard systems of yore, where half a dozen designers just made stuff up on their own without checking anything against each other, is eliminated. Systems have been created, and like with any new systems, there were hitches in a few assumptions here.
We’re fixing those assumptions (thanks in large part to some of the feedback provided here) and the systems will keep improving. We hope to avoid the typical “expansion item debacle” in the future by providing reasoned methods to make items in the future.
So yes, there were a few glitches here, but it’s all in the interest of progress.
Silius is doing an excellent job. If you think he’s doing his job in a vacuum, then you’re incorrect. Half the design team is working with him to make things better. Please feel free to continue to hate him, because that’s your prerogative, but he’s not going anywhere.
In response to a soon to be famous (?) quote from SmokeJumper:
There will be no further nerfs.
he clarified:
Okay, you guys are having fun baiting the devs. Nice work.
1) Just for the record, that quote is, of course, only pertaining to this week’s itemization. There was no way it implied no nerfs forever. Sheesh.
2) The stuff on Test is not a complete version of the itemization changes. Test uses a lot of the Live database and until we update stuff on Live, you won’t see all the changes.
3) There are no nerfs in tomorrow’s update.
We call him ‘Smokeblower’ in my guild, where we’ve been unimpressed with him since day one. And we aren’t exactly hardcore types, either–we can just tell when someone’s giving us a crock. Mark my words, there will be nerfs come the morning. Bank on it.